5. Intricate Enamel Pins & Bat-Wing Hair Accessories

Small, collectible hardware pieces fill empty corners of the basket and provide wearable tokens long after Halloween ends. Look for high-polish black nickel or gold enamel pins featuring morbid-sweet illustrations: candy-heart messages reading “Drop Dead,” dripping pastel eyeballs, or skeleton hands holding pink carnations. Add matching hair accessories, such as vegan leather bat-wing alligator clips, oversized black lace scrunchies, or pastel purple barrettes shaped like ribcages.